FAYETTEVILLE, Arkansas -  A Fayetteville woman was arrested after police say she stole $144 worth of eye shadow from an Ulta Beauty Store.

CBS affiliate KFSM 5News, reports that Brandy Allen grabbed handfuls of make-up off the shelves, stuffing them into her purse without checking the color or labels. When police arrived, Allen pulled out the make up and ran her fingers over it, trying to make the eye shadow looked used.

Allen, 31, cursed and broke one vial of eyeliner after insisting it was hers, but a clerk said she helped Allen pick it out at the counter, 5News reports.