Movie critic Michael Smith said it was the first time the words "sickening, grotesque and repugnant" all made it into the same review.
The film stars Casey Affleck, Jessica Alba and Kate Hudson. Affleck plays a deputy sheriff who is also a psychopathic killer. The movie was filmed in several Oklahoma locations including Tulsa and Oklahoma City.
4/28/2010 Related Story: Movie Shot In Oklahoma Premieres At NYC Film Festival
The violence is hard to watch because it is "over the top," Smith said Friday morning on Six in the Morning.
"Tulsa looks great it in," he said. "It's a beautifully shot film."
However, due to what he calls "bad decisions" on the part of the movie makers and the violence, he gave the film only one and a half stars.