Troubled LA Hospital Could Lose License After Woman Dies On Emergency Room Floor
Friday, June 22nd 2007, 4:37 pm
News On 6
LOS ANGELES (AP) _ When Edith Isabel Rodriguez showed up in the emergency room of an inner-city hospital complaining of severe stomach pain, the staff was already familiar with her.
It was at least her third visit to Martin Luther King Jr.-Harbor Hospital in as many days. ``You have already been seen, and there is nothing we can do,'' a nurse told her.
Minutes later, the 43-year-old mother of three collapsed on the floor screaming in pain and began vomiting blood. Employees ignored her, and she was soon dead.
Now state officials are threatening to close the hospital unless it can be improved, and Rodriguez has become a symbol of everything wrong with the facility derisively known as ``Killer King.''
After she collapsed, surveillance cameras show that Rodriguez was left for dead on the floor.
Nurses walked past her. A janitor cleaned up around her. No one did anything until police were called to cart her away. They didn't get far before she went into cardiac arrest and died.
``This needs to stop,'' state Health Services Director Sandra Shewry said Thursday as the agency moved to revoke the hospital's license. ``We're doing this in response to the egregious incidents that have come to light in the last six weeks.''
The hospital, formerly known as Martin Luther King Jr.-Drew Medical Center, was built after the 1965 Watts riot to bring health care to poor, minority communities in south Los Angeles.
But it had been plagued by patient deaths blamed on sloppy nursing care, among other things. The county attempted over the last few years to correct the problems with a multimillion dollar rescue effort, disciplining workers, reorganizing management, closing the trauma unit and reducing the number of beds from 200 to 48.
After Rodriguez's death, federal reports showed those efforts were failing and patients were in ``immediate jeopardy.'' Of the 60 cases reviewed between February and June, more than a quarter received substandard care, according to the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
In February, a brain tumor patient languished in the emergency room for four days before his family drove him to another hospital for emergency surgery. A pregnant woman who complained of bleeding was given a pregnancy test and left, only to return three days later and have a miscarriage after waiting more than four hours to see a doctor.
The findings have sent county officials scrambling to improve care before a federal inspection due by Aug. 15 that could determine whether the hospital keeps its federal funding. The county might close the facility without that money.
The hospital could contest the allegations in a hearing before a Department of Health Services administrative law judge.
``I'm losing hope,'' Zev Yaroslavsky, member of the county Board of Supervisors that oversees King-Harbor, told hospital managers earlier this week. ``We need to be prepared for the worst-case scenario.''
Even though hospitals nationwide struggle with too many patients and not enough staff, the scope and severity of King-Harbor's problems are rare.
``Most hospitals in America have long waits, they have crowded ERs,'' said Dr. Bruce Siegel, former chief of New York City's public hospitals and a George Washington University professor. ``But they don't let people die in the waiting room after they call 911. This is a whole new level here.''
Rodriguez, who struggled with drug addiction over the years, had visited King-Harbor several times for stomach pain in the days before she died. Each time, she was sent home, in some cases with pain medication, after doctors said she suffered from gallstones.
``They discharged me, but I don't feel good. I feel sick,'' she told her sister, Marcela Sanchez.
At the urging of her sister, Rodriguez returned to the hospital.
Early on May 9, she was wheeled into the ER by county police officers.
``Thanks a lot, officers, she's a regular here,'' a nurse said. ``She has already been seen and was discharged.''
After the nurse again refused to help, Rodriguez slid off her wheelchair and onto her knees in a fetal position, screaming in pain, according to a federal report based in part on surveillance videotape.
Over the next half hour, hospital staff walked past her. Soon, her boyfriend, Jose Prado, who had left for about an hour, returned to the hospital.
``When I came back, I found her lying on the floor with blood coming out of her mouth,'' Prado said. ``She said, 'Honey, help me! Nobody will help me here!'''
He pleaded with medical staff and then a county police sergeant to intervene, but no one did.
``I told him she had blood in her mouth,'' Prado says he told the sergeant. ``But he told me, 'Don't worry, she just has chocolate in her mouth.''
Then he called 911.
``My wife is dying and the nurses don't want to help her out,'' he said in Spanish through an interpreter
``What's wrong with her?'' a dispatcher asked.
``She's vomiting blood,'' Prado said.
When the dispatcher refused assistance, he hung up and frantically ran back to Rodriguez.
``I just hugged her. I didn't know what else to do. I couldn't think of anything else,'' he said.
Eventually, officers arrested her on a parole violation.
Police wheeled her out of the ER, then returned minutes later after Rodriguez's heart had stopped. Autopsy results revealed she died of a perforated bowel that probably developed in the previous 24 hours, a condition that is often treatable if caught early enough.
``They took her outside to die like an animal,'' Prado said.
After her death, a triage nurse was put on leave, resigned and was reported to the state Nursing Board for investigation. Six others _ a nurse, two nursing assistants, and three hospital finance workers _ were disciplined. Sheriff's detectives, meanwhile, have opened a homicide investigation.
Rodriguez's family said little will ease their grief. They plan to sue and are seeking copies of the video surveillance tapes, which are being held as part of a criminal investigation.
``They took my sister,'' Sanchez said. ``It wasn't time for her to go.''