Senate Takes Up Barrett Nomination, Setting Up Final Confirmation Vote Next Week

Friday, October 23rd 2020, 1:49 pm
By: CBS News

The Senate is taking up the nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court on Friday, setting up a final confirmation vote by the full Senate on Monday.

Senators are expected to debate her confirmation through the weekend. Her nomination was advanced by the Judiciary Committee on Thursday, with all 12 Republican members of the committee voting in favor, while all 10 Democrats on the committee boycotted the vote. At their committee seats, they placed life-sized photographs of Americans who benefit from the Affordable Care Act. 

Democrats argue that Barrett would vote to overturn the nation's health care law, and they've raised the possibility that this could come soon, since the court is about to take up a case on the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act days after the election. President Trump, who nominated Barrett, has repeatedly said that he wants the Supreme Court to overturn the ACA.

Senate Democrats may try to slow down Barrett's confirmation process with some procedural maneuvers, arguing, for instance, that the Judiciary Committee vote was illegitimate because no member of the minority was present. But there was a quorum of committee members present on Thursday, so Republicans are likely to respond that the vote complied with Senate rules. Democrats may also offer more procedural votes to draw out the process, like calling for a vote to adjourn until after the election.

The procedural maneuvering began as soon as the Senate convened, with Schumer forcing all senators for a "live quorum call," a roll call where every senator has to declare that they are present. He then called for an in-person vote to proceed with the legislative session, and forced the Senate to convene for a rare closed session to "talk face to face about what this might mean for the country." However, these tactics are not expected to delay the inevitable cloture vote for long.

Democrats have been slamming Republicans for pushing Barrett's confirmation so close to Election Day, after President Obama's Supreme Court nominee, Judge Merrick Garland, was denied a seat on the court in 2016. Republicans blocked Garland's nomination to fill Justice Antonin Scalia's vacant seat, arguing at the time that a Supreme Court nomination should not be considered in an election year because voters should first be able to choose the president, who would then select a justice. Scalia had died nine months before the election, and Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died a month and a half before the 2020 election, after some states had already begun early voting. Now, Republicans say that it's appropriate to fill the vacant seat before the election, because they control both the Senate and the White House.

In his speech on the Senate floor, McConnell praised Barrett as an "exceptional nominee," and argued that "every escalation has been initiated from the other side." He blamed former Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid for invoking the "nuclear option" to change precedent so that only 51 votes were needed to pass presidential nominees except for Supreme Court nominees in 2013. McConnell then invoked the nuclear option for Supreme Court nominees in 2017. He also argued that Republicans had acted within the rules and within the constitution in blocking Garland's confirmation.

"Of course they didn't like it. But elections have consequences. And America chose a Republican Senate in 2014," McConnell said. Schumer hit back at McConnell in an impassioned speech, accusing him of promoting a "tit for tat convoluted version of history."

"The Republican majority is steering the Senate to one of its lowest moments in its long history," Schumer said, slamming Republicans for blocking Garland and then pushing to confirm Barrett. "You don't have the right to argue consistency when you're doing what you're doing now."

Schumer accused Republicans of "conducting the most rushed, most partisan, and least legitimate process in the entire history of Supreme Court nominations." He also noted that nearly 50 million Americans have already voted.

"The Republican majority's monomaniacal drive to confirm this justice in the most hypocritical, the most inconsistent of circumstances, will forever defile the Senate and even more importantly, curtail the fundamental rights of the American people for generations to come," Schumer said.

Two Republican senators, Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski, have expressed opposition to confirming a justice ahead of the election. Murkowski and Collins both voted against going into executive session to allow McConnell to file cloture on Barrett's nomination. However, every other Republican is expected to vote to confirm Barrett.

Barrett's confirmation would give conservatives a strong 6-3 majority on the court. Democrats have raised concerns that Barrett could be a critical vote in overturning or restricting the rights to abortion and same-sex marriage. At her confirmation hearings last week, Barrett declined to indicate how she would rule on cases pending before the court.

First published on October 23, 2020 / 12:05 PM

© 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.