Legal or illegal? A copyright lawyer sets it straight

The Dallas Morning News asked Kelly Kordzik, intellectual property attorney with Winstead Sechrest & Minick, to answer basic questions about what&#39;s legal and illegal about file-sharing programs.<br><br>Q:

Friday, June 23rd 2000, 12:00 am

By: News On 6


The Dallas Morning News asked Kelly Kordzik, intellectual property attorney with Winstead Sechrest & Minick, to answer basic questions about what's legal and illegal about file-sharing programs.

Q: Theoretically, isn't downloading any single MP3, piece of commercial software or video a violation of the law?

A: If you don't have permission from the author or copyright holder, you have violated the copyright by downloading it.

Q: So even if I download illegally and delete it frommy drive, I have still violated the copyright laws?

A: The mere act of copying was a violation.

Q: Realistically, what are the risks I face?

A: They (music and record companies) are not going into everybody's homes and suing individuals for copying a song. The damages are minimal - the cost of a CD. What they're going to do is look for someone with deeper pockets to sue.

Q: The Audio Home Recording Act of 1992 allows for the use of digital audio recording devices for personal, noncommercial recording of copyrighted music - without liability. So why can't I make my legal copies available for others?

A: Well, you're contributing to the copyright infringement by someone else. I think a person who opens their files on the Internet could be held liable for contributory infringement. But again, is anyone going to go after you? No.

Q: So the individual users of these programs are really safe from any threat?

A: There's the potential with the Internet that someone can track who is downloading their material, then send out mass letters to everybody. Maybe they could scare some people into paying $5 or something. But I think an individual can be relatively safe. Microsoft doesn't go after individuals. But they do hire agencies and law firms, and they do go after companies.
logo

Get The Daily Update!

Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox!

More Like This

June 23rd, 2000

September 29th, 2024

September 17th, 2024

July 4th, 2024

Top Headlines

December 12th, 2024

December 12th, 2024

December 12th, 2024

December 12th, 2024